Having been born in 1990, I’ve encountered a lot of really bad sports seasons in my Cincinnati fandom – the mid-2000’s Reds seasons were pretty much all painful, 2010 for the Bengals was rough (we’ll get there), and the recent era of the Bengals where everyone loathes Marvin Lewis doesn’t sit well either. Keeping in mind that I was pretty young in the 90’s, and therefore can’t recall much about the abysmal Bengals of the time (researching it just isn’t the same), the 2008 Bengals were dreadful to watch.
The offense lost the pop it had had for the last few seasons, there was growing impatience with Marvin Lewis and Chad Johnson, and the Bengals simply didn’t win many games. There had only been one playoff season in the Lewis era at this point, but the team had at least been around the .500 mark, a marked improvement from the doldrums of the 90’s. What brought this team to such a screeching halt?
We’ll get to that, but first, our fun facts – which, by the way, were slim-pickin’s this week. The Dark Knight was the year’s top movie, which stunned me that that movie is now that old. Flo Rida and T-Pain topped music charts with Low, singing about apple-bottom jeans and furry boots. And one that I had to choose from a personal standpoint – 2008 marked the second season of Kitchen Nightmares, which was Gordon Ramsey’s version of Bar Rescue. If you don’t know what either of those are, I apologize. To the point – every restaurant that Chef Ramsey “saved” on season two of the show wound up closing following his trips to each place.
On the positive side, 2008 was the first season Mike Zimmer took over as the team’s defensive coordinator, replacing Chuck Bresnahan whose contract had expired at the end of 2007. Past that, the offseason was very similar to 2007 for our Bengals – lots of losses to free agency and a Draft that was, overall, a miss.
The Bengals lost four starters, one of which was All-Pro defensive end Justin Smith, who left town for San Francisco. They also lost safety Madieu Williams, veteran offensive tackle Willie Anderson, and running back Rudi Johnson. In addition, given wide receiver Chris Henry’s ongoing legal problems, the team wound up cutting him, with Marvin Lewis declaring he would never play for the Bengals again. It wasn’t long before Henry was brought back, but had to first serve a four-game suspension.
And finally, the Odell Thurman issue was finally put to bed. He was reinstated to the league before training camp after two full seasons of suspensions, but the Bengals waived him. He wound up violating the league’s substance abuse policy, and was suspended from the NFL indefinitely.
On the Draft side of things, the 2008 class had some names you probably remember – Keith Rivers, Jerome Simpson, Pat Sims, Andre Caldwell, and Anthony Collins. Those guys had their moments, especially Collins’ showing in recent years before he left for Tampa Bay and the big money, but it would be hard to consider that draft class any better than ‘okay’.
And here we are, at the start of the season… which ultimately ended with the team going 4-11-1. They opened the season 0-8 before finally upending the Jacksonville Jaguars as they went into their Week 10 bye. A 13-13 tie against the Eagles followed, and Cincinnati would close the season with three straight wins to rebound from a really bad 1-11-1 start.
A huge reason for the 2008 struggles had to do with Carson Palmer. He started the first three games of the season, as well as the fifth game, before it was determined he had a partially torn ligament and tendon in his elbow. Palmer passed on Tommy John surgery, but his need to rest the injury and not throw ended his season. Enter Ryan Fitzpatrick, who has managed to find a way into a starting lineup everywhere he’s been…. I have conspiracy theories about the guy.
Fitz was, in a word, bad. In Palmer’s absence, he threw for 1,905 yards and eight touchdowns, but he threw nine interceptions and fumbled a whopping seven times. This was still very early in Fitzpatrick’s career, but it stands as one of his worst showings in his storied career.
TJ Houshmandzadeh, Chris Henry, and Chad Johnson suffered mightily due to the quarterback issues. Chad notched his worst season in a Bengals’ uniform since his rookie year, reeling in 53 passes (on 97 targets) for 540 yards and four touchdowns – it’s also worth noting that he missed three games. Henry managed 19 catches and two scores in his limited action. Houshmandzadeh actually wasn’t bad, catching 92 balls for 904 yards and four touchdowns of his own.
A new look running game began to take shape following Rudi Johnson’s departure – former first-round pick Cedric Benson joined the Bengals in 2008, and he racked up 747 yards and two touchdowns. Those aren’t too impressive, but he only had ten starts. Chris Perry saw increased workloads as well, but failed to take advantage – he logged 269 yards on a very disappointing 2.6 yards per carry.
While Zimmer had taken over the defensive duties, there wasn’t much to write home about on that side of the ball either. Leon Hall and Johnathan Joseph were okay in coverage (‘okay’ being used since we know how good these two would end up being), and Dhani Jones logged one of his best seasons with hands in three turnovers and 75 tackles. But, with Smith gone, there were no true playmakers left for the defense to lean on.
And with 2008 (mercifully) behind us, we arrive at 2009, which was another season that featured the highest of highs and the lowest of lows, but the lows we experienced as a city and franchise in 2009 stretched far from the football field. It’s one of the seasons I’ve really been looking forward to talking about, so join me next week as we inch closer towards the beginning of 2018!
The Bengals fans guide to Super Bowl LIII
It’s been 30 years since the Cincinnati Bengals last played in a Super Bowl. A heartbreaking 20-16 loss to the San Francisco 49ers was the Bengals most recent shot at glory, and while Sunday’s matchup between the New England Patriots and the Los Angeles Rams showcases how far Cincinnati is to breaking that drought, there are plenty of things for Bengals fans to focus on inside of Mercedes-Benz Stadium.
Keep an Eye on the Incoming Head Coach
Zac Taylor is taking the reins from Marvin Lewis in what will be the first head coaching change since I started watching Bengals games during that magical 2005 season. The 35-year old Rams QB coach joins six other “young, offensive-minded” hires from this years coaching carousel. For Bengals fans, they are hoping he’s a cut above the rest, despite being the last to ink a deal. Bengals faithful should pay close attention any and every time the CBS production crew decides to show him in action on Sunday.
This is the biggest game Taylor has been a part of since entering the NFL coaching ranks with the Dolphins back in 2012 and it will be really interesting to see him handle a moment all Bengals fans hope he can relive sooner rather than later in Cincinnati. No one on the outside of the Rams organization really knows how involved Taylor is with setting up the gameplan, but he has clearly had a very positive effect on Jared Goff since taking over his tutelage in 2017.
How he interacts with Goff in between plays and coaches him through mistakes could go a long way in determining how he will help Andy Dalton (or Ryan Tannehill?) return to his 2015 form. Zac Taylor might not be the most experienced coach getting a chance this year but the results with Goff prove he deserves this opportunity.
Pre-snap and Play-Action
There are still questions as to who will call plays and control the 2019 Bengals offense, but in saying that fans should expect a lot of carryover from this Rams system that has willed their way to Atlanta with pre-snap communication and play-action passing. It’s no secret that Goff and Rams head coach Sean McVay communicate right up to the 15-second cutoff during every play.
McVay can read the defense, then call something to match their formation and he often times uses motion to accomplish that. Former Bengals offensive coordinator Bill Lazor was allergic to this kind of communication and the offense ranked 32nd and 26th in his two seasons because of it. Expect Taylor to have his voice in the Red Rifle’s ear plenty on Sundays.
In terms of play-action passing the Rams used these plays as the cornerstone of their offense, calling them 34 percent of the time with devastating effect. LA’s 9.0 yards per play on these calls ranked third in the NFL and they averaged 1.9 yards per play more than regular calls. On the flip side, Cincinnati ranked 13th in the league calling play-action on 24 percent for 1.5 yards per play more than all other calls. It’s not rocket science, play-action works wonders in today’s NFL and Taylor is expected to bring that mindset with him to the Queen City.
Todd Gurley: The Receiver
Player A: 55 targets, 43 receptions, 296 yards, 6.9 yards per catch, 1 TD
Player B: 81 targets, 59 receptions, 580 yards, 9.8 yards per catch, 4 TD
Yes, I know Joe Mixon had a stellar year running the ball (1,168 yards, 4.9 yards per carry) but he was totally mismanaged in the passing game and his Player A numbers reflect that. Player B, well I’d say he was used correctly and will continue to be used that way on Sunday. Despite his two costly drops in the NFC Championship Game, Todd Gurley is still one of the best receiving backs in the NFL.
A big reason why he’s so productive is the way LA puts him in an ideal position to make big plays, whether it’s a wheel route down the sideline or a throwback screen off of…. play action, this coaching staff does all they can to help him gash defenses. So far in Mixon’s career, I’ve barely seen any of that, it’s similar to putting a governor on a 66′ Cobra. Keep an eye on how the Rams use Gurley’s receiving skills to their advantage and imagine Mixon on the other end of those throws.
This One’s For Whit
Every Bengals fan should be rooting for the new head coach to bring a Super Bowl winning pedigree with him to his new digs in Cincinnati, but if that wasn’t enough, we should all be rooting for Andrew Whitworth.
Likely on his way to back-to-back All-Pro selections Whitworth is one of the best players to ever play the tackle position and was a consummate professional during his 11-year stint in a Bengals uniform. He notched his first playoff win 13 years into his career and why not knock down all of the playoff milestones in one run. I know who I’m rooting for come Super Bowl Sunday.
Enjoy the holiday.
An Open Letter to Marvin Lewis
Dear Mr. Lewis,
I have been contemplating sending you this letter for quite some time, and I hope it finds you well. You don’t know me, but I am a loyal fan of the Cincinnati Bengals. The second Super Bowl loss to the San Francisco 49ers remains as the first time I can remember experiencing heartbreak. I have, quite literally, hated Joe Montana for what he did to my then 12 year old self, for 30 years now. That said, my fandom has endured. Admittedly, as I was in college in the late 90’s, I was not as honed in on every move my Bengals made. So many losses, so little time. Sure, I loved Jeff Blake, Corey Dillon, and Takeo Spikes, but I had finals to take and parties from which to recover. But then something happened. Something unexpected. Mike Brown hired you as the head coach of the Cincinnati Bengals in 2003. Marvin Lewis – the legendary architect of one of the greatest defenses in the history of the league – was coming to be our coach! The excitement was palpable, and you were brimming with confidence. It was a swagger not seen around here since the days of Sam Wyche.
As the years passed, you began to place your stamp on the team and the city. The Marvin Lewis community fund is an outstanding work of art, and a tribute to your dedication to the people of Cincinnati. Kudos. On the field, the likes of Carson Palmer, Chad Johnson, Rudi Johnson, Willie Anderson, and TJ Houshmandzadeh, made being a Bengals’ fan fun again. They became must see TV, if not in person appointment viewing. Cleveland was a guaranteed two wins. Baltimore was almost two. Pittsburgh was likely a couple of losses, but the wins were sweet, and the losses were respectable. I’d look forward to your post-game interviews, and your Monday press conferences. There was useful information to be gleaned from them. Things that the average fan would miss as they had long turned off the broadcast and moved on with their lives. Not me. I am a loyal fan, remember? I don’t break down tape or have some hot draft take, but I love my Bengals, and I follow them closely – you included.
I need to take a moment to give you some props on the transition from the Palmer-era to the Dalton-era. That entire thing was a mess, what with Carson forcing his way out, you hiring an unproven offensive coordinator in Jay Gruden, and then drafting/starting a rookie quarterback in Andy Dalton. And all during an NFL lockout. I still remember predictions of the team going 0-16 that year. Somehow, some way, you guided this team, not only to a winning record, but to the playoffs. I am not sure if I have ever been more impressed by an NFL coach. You completely rebooted the franchise, and had a whole new cast of characters for us to get to know. Dalton, AJ Green, Geno Atkins, Carlos Dunlap, Clint Boling, and Andrew Whitworth. Young talent, ready to take on the AFC North. Two wins versus Cleveland – check. Almost two wins versus Baltimore – check. Still two losses to Pittsburgh – yeah, most of the time, but division titles weren’t out of reach. The playoffs became an annual event. This is where I need to touch on the obvious…
I do not understand your philosophy when it comes to playoff games, and for that matter, night games, games against Pittsburgh, Monday Night Football games, and any other game not at 1 pm eastern. You seem to have think and preach that these games are just the same as any other. No need for extra emphasis. No need for extra hype. No need to bring an extra chin strap because it’s just another game. After watching 16 years of this approach from you, I humbly disagree. Your teams are consistently outplayed, out-coached, and seemingly unprepared for the spotlight of these match-ups. At some point, would it not make sense to try a different approach? Maybe call it Pittsburgh week? Maybe say this Sunday night game is going to be huge for us? Maybe say that your team is chomping at the bit to play on Monday Night Football? It’s got to be better than just another game – just another loss.
I know you love this city and this franchise. I genuinely believe you want to win – for Mike Brown, and for the fans. That said, I think that it is time to move on with your life’s work. You gave it your all. You got more out of Mr. Brown than anyone ever thought possible. You raised this franchise to a level of respectability that no one could have predicted. You have done good work. It’s just not enough. There is no shame in that. And if I am being honest, you just do not seem to enjoy this anymore. Your press conferences, that I used to look forward to hearing, are all the same. Short, full of disdain for the people asking questions, and random giggles that make no sense. The fire and energy after 16 years of being an NFL head coach have faded. Why not let someone else give it a shot? We both know Mike Brown isn’t going to fire you, so why not walk away? Do what’s best for the franchise, and make them look for a coach. Last time, it brought us you!
Thank you for reading, and I wish you all the best in your next adventure.
P. S. Please take Hue Jackson with you. Thanks
Blog of Football Sorrows: Week 13
Today I officially changed the name of this game recap blog. It just fits. To be positive about this iteration of the Bengals is to be a master of the mind that I cannot comprehend (aka delusional).
They’re done. I didn’t think they had much hope for the playoffs before the game, and they certainly don’t now. The injuries are a problem, but they aren’t the problem. The offense has been stale for weeks thriving on an identity-less scheme filled with dink and dunk passes and zero creativity. They now have four games left. The Raiders seem winnable, but with the hope of starting over, do we fans want that? Do we want there to be a glimmer of hope in management’s eyes? I don’t. I want change, and that doesn’t happen by winning any remaining games, this year. Lose em all, blow it up, let’s start fixing the problems that have been ignored for too long.
Jeff Driskel, to no fault of his own, was meh. Which is much the story of 2018. The game plan, in the beginning, seemed to be for him to get momentum built through screens and flat routes…but then they kept the training wheels on. Second quarter, third quarter…it kept going. The Bengals fell behind on the scoreboard and their answer was to run more crossing routes and short outs? Cincinnati ran RPO plays…and only passed. They asked an athletic quarterback who can move to stand tall in the pocket and fend off pressure from a defense with its ears pinned back matching up with a bad and battered offensive line. Kind of like James mentioned on the post-game pod, how bad is Cedric Ogbuehi that the answer to filling in for Cordy Glenn is the starting left guard and not your former first round pick, who is actually supposed to be a left tackle? So the coaching game plan was to tell Driskel to grin and bear it behind an uninspired line with uninspired play calling? But, you know, Marvin Lewis says “We’ve got to do our jobs better. The players have to execute the game plan the way it is coached.” What? The game plan hasn’t changed in 10 years! Different personnel, different opponents, different circumstances, same stale, boring, dull, lifeless, clueless plan. I get sick to my stomach when I listen to Marvin do a press conference.
The only thing left is the future, whatever may come. I know that is bleak. Not one of you reading these words can say, with a straight face, that you can see a different coach roaming the sidelines in 2019 who isn’t Marvin or Hue Jackson. We know. We know there isn’t going to be any change, and that’s why the stadium is empty. That’s why the orange in the stands at Paul Brown Stadium was Bronco orange and not Bengal orange. The sound at the end of the game? Cheers and applause, because anyone still there was a fan of the visiting victors. There’s no one left to boo because they’ve been booing for so long they’ve lost interest. It is understood that the most likely outcome this season, if change comes at all, is that Hue takes the reigns. We’ll go from a boring, uninspired, regularly out-maneuvered coach to a joke of a coach. So how can anyone care? I looked at tickets before the game. You could have sit 12 rows back in the endzone for $35…and I said no. Why? Because the joke that is the visual of the stands at PBS is the last thing we fans have left to tell ownership to get their rear in gear and fix this. Will they? You tell me…
Follow @jefffcarr and @lockedonBengals on Twitter for more angst Bengals content.